Tag Archives: Malaysian Airlines

Tragedy above Ukraine – 10 points about MH17

As most people will have heard by now, on Thursday afternoon a Malaysian airlines flight was shot down over the conflict zone in Eastern Ukraine. All 295 on board died, including 154 Dutch citizens. While much is still unclear about the crash, there are still a number of points that can be made.

Who did it?

  • The most likely cause is that the jet was shot down by pro-Russian separatists. They have shot down Ukrainian military planes before, including one carrying almost 50 soldiers. They also boasted on social media about shooting down a plane, before deleting the posts.
  • The Ukrainian army on the other hand has no reason to shoot at planes. The government would certainly not want this to happen, and it would be an unlikely accident as well. The separatists don’t use aircraft (certainly not at the high altitude MH17 was flying at) and the Ukrainians know which planes are in their airspace.
  • It was however most likely a mistake. The separatists lack access to air control information or good radar, meaning that they probably had no idea what they were shooting at.
  • It is extremely unlikely that either the Ukrainians, nor the separatists, nor the Russians would purposefully shoot down a commercial jet. It serves no purpose, and would be a horrific crime.

How did this happen?

  • Commercial jets flying at these altitudes can’t be hit with handheld missiles, like have been uses before in the area. It would require a much bigger system, according to experts the Buk missile system. The Buk also requires trained men to launch it.
  • The blame for this will land squarely at Russia’s feet. They have been encouraging the separatists in the Donetsk region and allowing Russian and Chechen ‘adventurers’ to cross the border and play at soldiers, with the sole purpose of creating chaos. They have also allowed all sorts of weapons to cross over, and the role their security services are playing is very murky. They are responsible for dragging Eastern Ukraine into war.
  • The other question being asked is: What was MH17 doing there? It’s utterly bizarre that airlines were still flying a route that passes over militias with missiles. This will probably become a big issue.

What now?

  • According to current reports, the black box is on its way to Moscow. With trust at an all time low, Western countries (especially the Netherlands) will loudly call for an independent investigation.
  • This will destroy the separatists in the eyes of the world. If it’s fully proved they were responsible, they will have been shown to be trigger happy and careless. They don’t seem like freedom fighters, but more like violent and foolish adventurers.
  • Russia will probably have to take a big step back from its support for the rebels. Backing militias shooting down jets will do terrible damage to their image on the world stage. Putin has already said that it’s the fault of the country whose airspace the plane was in, but he is the one heavily responsible for the violent condition of parts of that country.

With the news cycle moving fast, the attention will quickly focus on the political responses to the attack. Tonight though, the Netherlands especially is mourning the loss of 154 of its citizens. In such a small country, such a tragedy has a terrible impact. It can only be hoped that this disaster can open the eyes of those involved in the conflict, and bring it to a swift and just end.

To find out more about the conflict in Ukraine, click here.